How to Choose a PR Agency (and When In-House PR Is Better)
How to choose a PR agency comes down to matching the model to your goal. Here's how agencies compare with in-house PR, the pricing models, a shortlist checklist and the red flags.
Short answer: start with the result you need and how fast you need it. Hire an agency when you need media relationships and results within weeks; build in-house PR when you have steady news, a budget for a full-time hire, and time to build relationships. Then choose the agency model, retainer or guaranteed placements, that matches how much risk you want to carry.
PR agency vs in-house PR
| Factor | PR agency | In-house PR |
|---|---|---|
| Speed to first coverage | Weeks, using existing media relationships | Months, while relationships are built |
| Cost | A retainer or fixed project fees | A salary plus tools, every month |
| Knowledge of your company | Learns it during onboarding | Deep, and always on hand |
| Media relationships | Broad, across many outlets | Narrower at first |
| Best for | Launches, executive visibility, fast credibility | Ongoing communications at scale |
Get a free article about your company on The Tech Tier. Usually live in minutes.
Get my free articleHow to choose an agency, step by step
- Write down the goal: launch coverage, executive visibility, investor credibility, or an ongoing program.
- List the 10 publications your buyers actually read.
- Shortlist 3 to 5 agencies that have placed companies like yours on those publications recently.
- Compare models: a retainer buys time; a guaranteed package buys results.
- Ask for links, not logos, and check them on the publication's own site.
- Agree how success will be measured before you sign.
How to compare PR agencies side by side
Put your shortlist in one table and ask every agency the same questions. Vague answers are an answer too.
| What to compare | What to ask | A good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Results | Which outlets did you get clients like us on in the last 90 days? | Live links on the exact publications your buyers read |
| Guarantee | What happens if a placement doesn't go live? | A written replacement or refund policy, with a time limit |
| Speed | When will the first article be live? | A specific range, such as days or weeks, not 'it depends' |
| Pricing model | Is this a retainer, a project or per placement? | Clear pricing tied to deliverables you can check |
| Team | Who works on our account day to day? | Named, senior people you can speak to before signing |
| Fit | Who is your typical client, by stage and sector? | Companies that look like yours, with case studies |
| Proof | Where can we read independent reviews? | Verified reviews on Clutch, Trustpilot or G2 |
| Contract | What's the minimum term and notice period? | Terms that match the results you're buying |
A note on "best PR agency" lists
Use round-up lists as a starting point, not a verdict. In our study of the sources AI tools cite, 60% of the "best X" and "X vs Y" articles were published by a company selling in that same category, and that includes PR agencies, us among them. Check who wrote a list, then verify each agency's claims with live coverage links and reviews.
Red flags
- Case studies with logos but no article links.
- Long minimum contracts with no defined results.
- Vague answers about who will work on your account.
- Sponsored posts presented as editorial coverage.
Fix your message before you hire PR
PR amplifies your story, so it can't fix a story that isn't clear. If buyers can't tell from your homepage what problem you solve and why it matters now, coverage will bring attention without conversions.
If that's you, start with messaging. We recommend PitchKitchen, a B2B messaging agency that helps tech companies sharpen their story and homepage. Its 2026 review of 250 B2B homepages found that only 2 named the cost of inaction.
A PR agency RFP template for marketing teams
If you're collecting proposals from several agencies, send each one the same brief so the answers are comparable. A one-page RFP covering these points is enough:
- Company background: what you sell, to whom, and the markets you sell in.
- Goals for PR: brand credibility, thought leadership, a launch, a raise, or demand support, and how you'll judge success.
- Who needs to be visible: the company, the CEO, and any practice or regional leaders.
- Target publications and regions, in priority order.
- Topics you want to be known for in the next 12 months.
- Budget range and timeline, including when you want to start.
- What each agency must send back: 5 recent placement links for companies like yours, the named team, the pricing model and minimum term, what is guaranteed and what isn't, and how they report results.
A simple scorecard to compare the answers
| Criterion | What good looks like | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Relevant recent placements | Live links on the publications your buyers read, for companies like yours | 30% |
| Clarity of what you get | Named outlets or a clear number of placements, and what happens if one doesn't publish | 25% |
| Team | Senior people named in the proposal, with time on your account | 15% |
| Fit with your markets and executives | Coverage in your regions and a plan for each leader | 15% |
| Reporting | Monthly results against your goals, not activity counts | 15% |
What AI assistants read when you ask them to recommend a PR agency
In October 2026 we asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews 30 B2B buying questions and logged about 1,050 sources behind 120 answers.
For "best X" questions, about half of the cited sources were third-party list articles; for "X vs Y" questions, about 61% were. Of the list and comparison articles Perplexity and Google cited, 60% were written by a company selling in the same category. Questions about a named company leaned on review sites.
So treat an AI answer as a starting shortlist, not a verdict: open the sources it cites, check who wrote each list, and ask every agency for live coverage links from the last few months.
Specialist shortlists
If your company is in one vertical or city, start with a specialist comparison. Each guide is honest about when another agency fits better.
Where Jamco PR fits
Jamco PR is a tech PR agency for companies that want guaranteed placements on publications like Business Insider, USA Today and Yahoo Finance, without a long retainer. It's done for you: one questionnaire, then Jamco handles the story, writing, outreach and publication. If you need crisis communications, analyst relations or a large embedded team, a full-service agency is the better fit, and our comparison pages name some good ones.
Recent client results
Real Jamco PR placements you can read today. Most clients see their first article within 14 days.
Know a tech company that needs this? Refer them and earn 10% of their first payment.
Frequently asked questions
Should I ask ChatGPT which PR agency to hire?
It's a reasonable starting point, but check the sources. In our October 2026 study, 60% of the list articles AI tools cited for "best X" questions were written by a company selling in that same category. Open the cited lists, see who wrote them, and ask each agency for recent live coverage links.
What should a PR agency RFP include?
Your company background, goals for PR and how you'll measure them, which executives need visibility, target publications and regions, topics, budget range and timeline, and what each agency must send back: recent placement links, the named team, pricing model and minimum term, what is guaranteed, and how they report.
How do I choose the right PR agency?
Define your goal, list the publications your buyers read, shortlist agencies that recently placed companies like yours on them, check their article links, and compare retainer and guaranteed pricing models.
Is it better to hire a PR agency or build in-house PR?
An agency is faster when you need results within weeks, because it already has media relationships. In-house PR makes sense once you have steady news and budget for a full-time team.
What should I ask a PR agency before hiring it?
Ask for links to recent placements for companies like yours, which publications are realistic, whether results are guaranteed, who will work on your account, and how success will be measured.
How much does a PR agency cost?
Agency retainers are billed monthly and few agencies publish their rates (Crackle PR, for example, lists a $12,000 per month minimum). Jamco PR's fixed packages with guaranteed placements start at $5,000.
More guides
Client case studies
Our services
Want to get on top-tier publications?
Book a call and we'll show you which outlets fit your story, and how fast we can get you there.
Book a callGet a free article